The first Meetinghouse was raised in 1754 and its first minister, the Reverend Benjamin
Caryl, accepted the call in 1762, serving for fifty years. At this time, there were 352 inhabitants and 49 houses in Dover. (The image below, left, shows the First Parish Church, c. 1910)
In addition to ministering to his parishioners, Benjamin worked his farm and prepared young men for college. His theology appears to be standard for the period, but it is noteworthy that in his sermons he changed his opinion regarding involvement in the American Revolution. In
December 1766 he suggested the Parish
“be sensible of the mercy of God in continuing to us our sovereign and the happy government which at present we are under.”
But by March 1776, he thought that “[w]e doubt not that the omnipotent hand of our heavenly Father is ready to stretch forth and save us.”